Reformation Sunday #3
Why Not Rome?
Introduction
"This one thing I know, Christian," Charles Spurgeon once said, "you are not acting as you ought to do when you are moved by any other motive than the one motive of your Lord's glory." The sixteenth-century Protestant Reformation was, at its heart, a movement born of concern for the glory and honour of God. Why? Because of the unbreakable connection between the glory of God and God's revealed truth. To diminish his truth, especially his gospel, is to repurpose why all things were made to begin with.
The Reformers, such as Martin Luther, Ulrich Zwingli, John Calvin, and many others, had this concern about the state of Christianity and the communion of the Roman Catholic Church in their day. They saw that sound doctrine and true worship were all but lost to man-made layers of tradition, ceremony, and erroneous teaching, and that the gospel itself had been all but lost in that communion.
With reference to selected texts as we move along, I want to bring you this message entitled: "Why Not Rome?" We want to understand why the Reformation was not only important and necessary in its own day, but why this is still a living issue, why the fight for the truth of the gospel remains as important now as ever. Why? It is because the glory of God is at stake, and because eternal souls are at stake through this gospel.
These issues have not gone away. I acknowledge this can be a difficult subject for many Christians because the amount of overlap between Romanism and Protestantism can make people think that a Roman Catholic is perhaps, by default, just like a Christian in another denomination, like a Presbyterian might say about a Baptist, or a Baptist about a Presbyterian.
However, you may not realise that where it matters, the Reformers helped show the dark doctrinal underbelly of Rome and her corrupted beliefs. So much so that we are forced to say that if there are any born-again believers in the Roman Catholic communion, of which there will be, who are trusting in Christ alone through faith, they will be saved in spite of Rome's teaching, and certainly not because of it.
We are always in a fight for the truth, brothers and sisters. Gospel fidelity matters because the glory of God is at stake. I agree with John Calvin, who said of Catholicism: "I call them churches, inasmuch as the Lord there wondrously preserved some remains of his people, though miserably torn and scattered." Perhaps you will come to appreciate some of these things as we press forward.
A Question Of Authority
What, for you, at the end of the day is that sole authority which may uniquely command your life? What authority in your life do you consider binding? It speaks, you listen; it speaks, you do. This question was forefront at the Reformation, and it is, of course, an ongoing question.
If you are a Christian in a church tracing its heritage through the Protestant tradition, your answer ought to be given in the combined 66 books of the Old and New Testaments: the Bible. That is our authority. You will believe that in Scripture, through the inspiration of the Holy Spirit and through the personality of select men, God gave us a divinely breathed word. God himself has spoken in the words of Scripture, every jot and tittle. No other body of writings or teaching, no confession, creed, or catechism, should ever be considered in the same category as this Book.
You might think that what I have just said is rather obvious. Isn't that what all Christians believe? Well, here is a key area where the teaching of Roman Catholicism differs from that teaching we would argue is consistent with historic Christian belief. The issue of authority was called the formal cause of the Reformation. At the crux of this difference between Catholicism and Protestantism is the question of where our final authority lies, especially in spiritual matters and matters of the faith.
So what does Rome teach about Scripture? First, we should acknowledge that the Roman Catholic Church had and has a high view of Scripture. It does. This subject gets dense and complex, but to put it simply, leaving aside our differences regarding the apocryphal books not in the Protestant canon, we believe in Scripture alone as the sole and infallible source of divine authority.
In Roman Catholicism, however, you have Scripture plus church tradition. They would say that these are two bodies of divinely inspired authority. Alongside Scripture, they hold that the Magisterium, the Pope presiding in communion with his bishops and priests, is considered the infallible interpreter of Scripture, and that this body of interpretation is binding upon all in the Roman communion. Divine truth, therefore, in Roman Catholicism is not solely found in the words of Scripture, but in the interpretation of the Magisterium.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church says in paragraph 80: "Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture, then, are bound closely together and communicate one with the other. For both of them, flowing out of the same divine well-spring, come together in some fashion to form one thing, and move towards the same goal." In paragraph 82, it says that these two bodies are to be accepted and honoured with "equal sentiments of devotion and reverence".
This is hugely problematic, brothers and sisters. Protestant theologian R. C. Sproul said the following on this issue: "This raises the issue of dual-source theory of revelation. Are there two sources of revelation, Scripture and tradition, or is there one source, Scripture? The Protestant view is sola scriptura. That is, Scripture alone. God's special revelation comes only in the Scriptures. Other books may be of value for instruction. Even the Apocrypha is helpful to the church, though it is not revelatory. But the Roman Catholic Church historically recognizes two sources of revelation: Scripture and tradition."
What are the implications of this? The first point is that by raising a body of human knowledge up to stand alongside Scripture and saying that it uniquely agrees with Scripture, you inevitably diminish the authority of Scripture. You are monopolising it into a certain group of people who alone can authoritatively say what Scripture says.
A second point is that this view diminishes the emphasis on private devotion and study of the Word for oneself, because it becomes an outsourced enterprise. Why study the Word for yourself when you are just going to be told by someone else what it means?
A third point is that it disables the possibility of challenging the interpretation of those in church authority. If I preach a sermon to you next Sunday and exposit Habakkuk, and you see that there are problems with my exegesis in the way that I have interpreted and applied the Scriptures, you have the ability to come to me and challenge me on that. Not in Rome; you cannot do that.
At the risk of oversimplification, in Roman Catholicism the Pope is considered the infallible interpreter of Scripture on matters to which Scripture speaks; he is without error under certain conditions in faith and morals. I find it glaringly ironic that it was the apostle Paul who confronted Peter. Roman Catholics claim Peter was the first pope, the first head of the church, and yet even Peter needed correction by Paul. Nate Pickowicz writes: "In 1870, at the First Vatican Council, it was decreed that when the Pope speaks ex cathedra ('from his chair'), he is speaking on behalf of God, and thereby, his words are infallible."
So what are we to believe here? Turn with me to 2 Timothy 3:16-17, a well-known scripture to you. We want to have the understanding of divine authority that the Scriptures themselves teach us, because Scripture is that source. What does it say about itself? It says: "All Scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, for training in righteousness; so that the man of God may be adequate, equipped for every good work."
The apostle Paul sets forward for us, first, that Scripture is of divine origin; it is God-breathed. God never established, nor does he ever speak in his Word of establishing, any other body of such divinely breathed truth. He never speaks of any sole interpreters of Scripture outside the apostles themselves. Those books the church received through apostolic verification and acknowledged as Holy Scripture contain a peculiar glory that is present in no other body of truth, not even close. The Word is self-attesting in its message, its unity, and its interconnectedness; and the witness of the Holy Spirit enables the people of God to perceive Scripture as Scripture, as God's Word for them. Jesus said to the Jews, "search the Scriptures". The Bereans were commended for their nobility as they searched the Scriptures for themselves. All who want to know what God has said must search the Scriptures; it is God-breathed.
Paul also shows us that the Scriptures are sufficient. Paul makes Timothy dependent on these apostolic and apostolically approved writings. He speaks of no enduring body that must be consulted, no pope that must first sign off on how it is interpreted. Scripture interprets Scripture; it is its own interpreter. The man of God can be adequately equipped by reference to this Scripture alone.
Wilhelmus à Brakel, the Dutch Puritan, says this: "Not one word in the Bible refers to an infallible earthly judge, but Scripture itself is established as judge. To its declarations we are to give heed as being the oracles of God."
So why not Rome? Because Rome has committed the great error of the Jewish elders in Jesus' day: Mark 7:8, "Neglecting the commandment of God, you hold to the tradition of men." This is not to say that confessions, such as the Westminster Confession of Faith, creeds, such as the Apostles' Creed, and church history cannot help us understand the Word, or even be used to lay down what we believe and confess Scripture teaches. We can do that. But even those sources are not to be treated as divinely authoritative in themselves. They are to be treated as subject to Scripture itself; they are not inspired, and they are, in fact, capable of error.
A Question Of Sufficiency
Each of these points could easily be its own message, so we must be brief. Here I want to say that the Roman Catholic Church errs in her teaching regarding the once-for-all sacrifice of Jesus Christ on the cross for the sins of his people and the sufficiency of that sacrifice to save all who believe. To consider this, we have to go to the Roman Catholic Mass and their practice of celebrating the Eucharist. "Eucharist" comes from a Greek word which simply means "thanksgiving"; this is their practice for celebrating the Lord's Supper as instituted by our Lord Jesus Christ.
What does Rome teach about the Eucharist, the bread, and the wine? Perhaps you have been to a Catholic Mass before, maybe at a funeral or elsewhere, and you have watched as the priest offers prayer, invoking the Holy Spirit, prepares with the Lord's Prayer, and breaks bread. The church and the priest are thought to implore the power of the Holy Spirit by that which is called transubstantiation, so that the wine and the bread are said to become Christ's body and blood in their substance. Their appearance and taste, those things we call accidents, will not change, but the substance, that which it is in its essence, they say literally becomes the body and blood of Christ. To quote from one Catholic liturgy: "that the unblemished sacrificial victim to be consumed in communion may be for the salvation of those who will partake of it."
This doctrine of transubstantiation is itself quite a technical study. I spent basically all of Wednesday just trying to get my head around it for five minutes here on Sunday morning. But this has long been the teaching of the Roman Catholic Church. For instance, all the way back in the year 1079, Pope Gregory VII made another man take this oath on the Eucharist: "I believe in my heart and openly profess that the bread and wine that are placed on the altar are through the mystery of the sacred prayer and the words of the Redeemer substantially changed into the true and proper and life-giving flesh and blood of Jesus Christ our Lord, and that after the consecration, they are the true body of Christ."
The Reformers strongly opposed this teaching. The great problem is that Catholicism calls the Eucharist a holy sacrifice, a sacrificium, and our alarm bells should be going off as we hear that. They say that the death of Christ on the cross and the offering of the Eucharist in the Mass are one and the same sacrifice. In the Mass, the priest is supposed to mediate and apply Christ's atoning sacrifice to the recipient of the Eucharist.
The Lord's Supper is made into something in which the sacrifice of Christ is said to be perpetually given, so that the priest might declare absolution from sins, even for those who are in their supposed state of purgatory. "The Mass", said Martin Luther, "in the papacy has to be the greatest and most horrible abomination".
Listen to the Catechism of the Catholic Church again, paragraph 1366: "The Eucharist is thus a sacrifice because it re-presents (makes present) the sacrifice of the cross, because it is its memorial and because it applies its fruit."
The Reformers and Protestants not only deny this teaching, but believe that it corrupts the gospel message and what it communicates to all who take part. What permanence, what rest can I enjoy in Christ if in the Mass I must go again and again and again to Christ's sacrifice? Where is the assurance? Where is the finality? How can I even know that the works of Christ have been applied to me when I must access them by this work at each Mass, and that through a human, fallible priest? Did not Christ offer himself to the Father once for all, or must I now look to a priest to offer my Jesus again and again to the Father?
Wilhelmus À Brakel deconstructs Rome's view to summarise why it is lunacy to hold that the death of Christ and the Eucharist in the Mass are the same sacrifice:
First, he says, the priest differs. On the cross, Christ was the priest; Christ was our intercessor, offering himself to the Father. But in the Mass, it is a fallen, fallible man claiming to offer Christ to the Father.
Secondly, the altar differs. In Matthew 23:19, the Lord Jesus speaks of the altar sanctifying the sacrifice; in the sacrifice of Christ, he himself is the altar, not a wooden or stone table as in the Mass.
Thirdly, the sacrifice itself differs. On the cross, Christ's real body was crushed for us and his real blood was shed for us, but Rome fabricates a view called transubstantiation to support their claim.
Fourthly, the location is not the same. Christ died once for all at Golgotha, not in many locations.
Fifthly, Jesus' death occurred on behalf of those in the world before him and after him, once for all, a timeless sacrifice. The Mass constrains itself to repeated communions.
Sixthly and finally, the efficacy is not there in the Roman Mass. Though they say it is one sacrifice, they call it a holy sacrifice, a sacrificium, that must be repeated. A sacrifice to be repeated is no sacrifice at all, and it is not sufficient, here is the key term, it is not sufficient to atone for sin. If repeated Masses are required, for example, to help a soul escape purgatory, then the Mass itself cannot accomplish the full atonement that it claims to represent.
We have to be precise on these things, dear friends; souls are at stake. This all contrasts with the complete efficacy of Christ's finished sacrifice.
Turn now to Hebrews 10:10-12. What is the biblical teaching? Where are we to go, and no further, when we speak about what Christ has done? Hebrews 10:10: "By this will we have been sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all. Every priest stands daily ministering and offering time after time the same sacrifices, which can never take away sins", speaking of the Levitical priesthood, "but He, having offered one sacrifice for sins for all time, sat down at the right hand of God."
The idea is of an efficacious, completed sacrifice once for all. Where in such a text is there even a jot or tittle of room to do what Rome does? What a twisting of the gospel. What a failure to communicate what Christ has won for all time for his people, when one must come to each Mass and hear of Christ being perpetually offered from Golgotha to the Father through a fallible man. Christ has been sacrificed once for all, and his sacrifice is perfect. It is not perpetual; it is permanent, and it is accessed through faith.
Rather than honouring Christ's true sacrifice, Rome vainly misconstrues its finality and efficacy for all who believe. Listen again to paragraph 1128 of the Catholic Catechism: "Nevertheless, the fruits of the sacraments also depend on the disposition of the one who receives them." In the Eucharist, Christ is being truly offered, they say, for the atonement of sins, and the fruits of Christ's atonement are being applied as it is taken; and yet they say the disposition of the one who receives them has to be adequate.
What a nuclear bomb dropped on assurance! How can I even know if my disposition is correct? What if I enter the sanctuary and I have had a fight with my spouse in the car, we barely resolved it, my kids are upset, my disposition isn't right, and I am sinning in my heart against God? Where is my assurance? How can I know that Christ's blood pleads for me? What if my heart is not right, will Jesus have still died for me?
Rome, therefore, denies the basic premise of the biblical gospel: that we must look away from ourselves entirely, away from our disposition. Our disposition means nothing when the disposition of Christ towards his people is that of "forgiven, forgiven, forgiven". Rome puts men and women on a treadmill of works in the end, under the proviso of grace. The sufficiency of Christ for you is in Jesus, and it is in Jesus alone.
The Westminster Shorter Catechism rightly says: "Christ executeth the office of a priest, in his once offering up of himself a sacrifice to satisfy divine justice, and reconcile us to God, and in making continual intercession for us." Praise God.
A Question Of Salvation
We have seen a question of authority and a question of sufficiency; finally, we come to a question of salvation. I said earlier that the matter of sola scriptura was the formal cause of the Reformation, that was at the crux of the issue: where is the authority? Here we come to the material cause of the Reformation, that which sparked it all: how can a man or a woman be in right standing with God? This was the catalyst question of the Reformation, especially through the Augustinian monk and Catholic priest, Martin Luther. Luther came to see that Rome had it all backwards. In basic terms, the question at hand was: how can a person enter a permanent standing of justification, no longer under condemnation, totally at rest in the works of Christ on their behalf?
Frank Senn, the Lutheran scholar, makes this telling point in his work on the history of liturgy. He claims rightly that Luther's objection to the sacrifice of the Mass was that "it was being offered to God to procure God's favour apart from faith in the promises of God." In other words, Rome had turned the gospel inside out into something in which man was essentially making an offering to God, rather than God offering himself to man. This is the issue: is it the priest offering Christ to the Father, or is it Christ offering himself to the Father on our behalf? It is the latter. In this difference lies salvation itself; in this difference lies the eternal destination of the souls of men and women. Luther came to see that the Bible teaches we are saved with empty hands, which God fills by his grace.
So what does Rome teach about justification? First, I want to dispel some slander often repeated by Protestants who will just say blankly, "Rome teaches salvation by works." That is a horrible slander, and you make yourself easy pickings for a Roman Catholic theologian by saying that; it is not true at all. Rome teaches the necessity of faith, absolutely. What does happen, however, is that works are introduced at the wrong point. Rome confuses sanctification and justification; they confuse law and gospel. That is why it matters so much: get this wrong, and you get the gospel wrong.
Rome does not deny that justification begins with the grace of God. The disagreement is over what justification actually is. Rome includes our inward renewal within justification, rather than distinguishing God's declaration that we are righteous in Christ alone. In this way, sanctification and justification are horribly confused so that the gospel itself is confused. The sinner never really comes under this teaching to see that only the passive reception of Christ will ever be enough.
Listen to Rome in her own Catechism, paragraph 1989: "Justification is not only the remission of sins, but also the sanctification and renewal of the interior man." In other words, your day-to-day Christian life is in some way contributing to your justification, again, a nuclear bomb on assurance. The next paragraph, 2010, says: "Moved by the Holy Spirit and by charity, we can then merit for ourselves and for others the graces needed for our sanctification, for the increase of grace and charity, and for the attainment of eternal life." Dear friends, "merit" and "eternal life" should not be used in the same paragraph like that.
And consider this final quote from the Council of Trent in 1547, never retracted by Rome: "If any one saith, that justice received is not preserved and also increased before God through good works; let him be anathema." They are calling a curse upon anyone who would deny that works somehow contribute to our justification. What a total confusion of the gospel.
Let me conclude here by making these things clear, developing a short illustration used by John Calvin in his Institutes of the Christian Religion, which he first wrote in his mid-twenties. He speaks of the idea that when you and I keep our eyes low, looking around at earthly things, we will always feel comfortable with ourselves because our ability to see is strong and sound. But take a moment to look up into the sun, and instantly vision is wiped out; it completely perishes. You cannot look into the sun. Calvin says that when we lift our sights to God, our confidence is destroyed and shattered in an instant.
This is why justification and sanctification must never be combined, must never be confused. I cannot look into the sun without being blinded and dazzled by its brilliance, and I cannot look into the blazing holiness of God and think that there is anything in me to contribute, any merits of mine that I can bring on my way to eternal life. May it never be! One look into the blazing sun of God's holiness is enough to show me there is no righteousness in Rhys. He has nothing; he is in despair; he is full of sin.
Justification, our right standing with God, must be 100 percent the work of God. It must be the gift of God without any addition by us, or else we are leaving room for boasting in the flesh. Rome gets this confused, and the glory of God is diminished.
Listen to what Job said in Job 9:2-3: "In truth I know that this is so; but how can a man be in the right before God? If one wished to dispute with Him, he could not answer Him once in a thousand times." In other words, Job caught a glimpse of the blazing sun of God's holiness and saw that he had nothing to say and nothing to add.
As we conclude, let us turn to Romans 10:3-4: "For not knowing about God's righteousness and seeking to establish their own, they did not subject themselves to the righteousness of God. For Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to everyone who believes."
Paul, in the wider section here, is dealing with the question of why so many of the Jews in Jesus' day refused him as Saviour. Firstly, he says that one of the reasons they have fallen from Christ is that they have sought to establish their own righteousness; they did not subject themselves to God's righteousness. What is he saying? To use my previous illustration again, they had not looked up into the sun. They hadn't looked into the blazing sun of God's holiness, and so they thought there was some room for them to establish their own righteousness before God. If they had looked up into the sun, they would immediately have seen that their own striving to be righteous through the law was of no account.
Secondly, Paul says that Christ is the end of such striving. This is the good news; this is the gospel. He is saying that the righteousness of God is available through Jesus Christ. And by what means does he say it can be accessed? Believing. Believing, and you get all of God's righteousness. Christ is the end of the law because his life, death, and resurrection make it the end of the law. You don't have to earn it yourself; Jesus does it for you. What Jesus has done shows us that the law could not produce a right standing in us. Rather, through faith alone, God transmits all of his salvation, all of his righteousness to us, declaring us to be in right standing with him.
That is the starting point. Justification is at the beginning of the road, and out of that justification, God works our sanctification. He gets the Rhys out of Rhys; he gets the sin out of the sinner ever so slightly, and he does it, he empowers it, he drives it. As Paul says in Philippians, he who began a good work will complete it.
Romans 5:1: "Therefore, having been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ." What an assurance, that the one who believes might have all of Christ's benefits at his expense.
Conclusion
The cry of the Reformation came with this question of authority, and we have seen that it is Scripture alone. It came with this question of sufficiency, and we have seen that it is Christ alone. It came with this question of salvation itself, and we have seen that it is faith alone.